Asher Kelman
OPF Owner/Editor-in-Chief
How do you feel about these two 28mm little black brick cameras that are aimed at the serious photographer.
Here are two cameras, both offer RAW, have a 28mm fixed lens in solidly built pocketable cameras.
One, the 10MP Ricoh GR Digital II has the advantage of a fast superb 2.4 lens the other, the Sigma DP1 offers the advanced and much larger DSLR sized tri-layer RGB Foveon sensor, with the x3 factor, 14 MP. Have you considered these?
The ~ $600 GR Digital II already has a following because of the pedigree of its quality fixed 28mm lens and the unique grain (some would call it "horrible", others "distinctive") of the B&W images it can produce. For sure, the camera reacts fast and is blessed with perhaps the best set of buttons for manual control of everything including "favorite settings".
For the well received Ricoh, it's the fast lens that is the selling point. "The key criteria for lens performance , sharpness and low distortion, have been pursued without compromise. The widely acclaimed F2.4/f:5.9mm lens (35mm equivalent: 28mm) features improvements to compensate for various types of aberrations and vignetting on the subject's periphery - areas that are particularly problematic - to provide outstanding sharpness and high contrast all the way to the corners of the image as the data in the lens' MTF curve demonstrates. This achieves high image quality particularly when taking pan-focus shots. Other refinements include reduction in mechanical noise from the AF drive during focusing. The GR Lens is the story of constant efforts at improvement. The more the user understands photography, the more he or she will want to put this lens to use.
The brightness of a F2.4 aperture and various aberration compensation. The superb optical performance of the GR Lens is achieved by a 5-group, 6 element lens that incorporates 3-groups with 2 aspherical elements and high-precision assembly techniques for sharper images in a more compact size. Use of high quality optical glass and special lens polishing and multi-coating technologies ensure natural colour renditions, overall sharpness and excellent contrast characteristics. The design of an original "retracting lens system" allows for the lens to draw level into a thin, 25mm camera body. In the course of the lens retracting a portion of the optical system withdraws from atop of the optical axis, thereby realizing extreme high-precision and control of the lens unit - a successful merger of exceptional optical performance within a slim body form you can carry with you anywhere." Source.
I am impressed how photographers have become religiously attached to the Ricoh, even embracing the noise as some character like we might remark on in swirling a taste of a great wine. There's lens adapters to provide focal lengths equivalent 40mm and 21mm. Fans even crave versions with these 40mm and 21mm focal lengths and it seems many would carry all three! Hello guys! What's the point of a compact if you are schlepping a whole compendium of lenses and or variants!
I however, look to the upcoming ~ $800 Sigma DP1, for far greater quality image implied. A more impressive picture is expected from the Foveon sensor, as found in in the flagship Sigma SD14 DSLR. After a puzzling delay which appears to have been a matter of getting the last software quirks solved, the 28mm fixed lens DP1 is due out in Europe and the USA in weeks. The Sigma company has put both it's flagship larger Foveon sensor and it's lens expertise into its compact DP1 offering. "Sigma DP1 compact digital camera featuring a 14 megapixel FOVEON X3 direct image sensor (2652 _ 1768 _ 3 layers) as used in the Sigma SD14 digital SLR."
"16.6mm F4 LENS DESIGNED EXCLUSIVELY FOR THE DP1
The DP1 is equipped with a 16.6mm F4 lens, equivalent to 28mm on a 35mm SLR camera, which has been designed exclusively for DP1. The large-diameter of aspherical glass provides low distortion and high contrast images. It also offers superior peripheral brightness. The super multi-layer coating reduces flare and ghosting. It allows photographers to take pictures in difficult light conditions. This lens and SLR-sized image sensor provides natural shallow depth-of-field." Source Sigma
Well, what about the Sigma not having the 40mm lens for portraits? Just take the image and crop! What about a 21mm attachment like the Ricoh? Turn the camera vertically and take adjacent overlapping pictures. That's what stitching is for. One camera for everything! However, I'd guess it will be best used at ISO settings at 400 and below given the performance of the same sensor in the Sigma DSLR. At the lower ISOs one should get really wonderful color.
Asher
Here are two cameras, both offer RAW, have a 28mm fixed lens in solidly built pocketable cameras.
One, the 10MP Ricoh GR Digital II has the advantage of a fast superb 2.4 lens the other, the Sigma DP1 offers the advanced and much larger DSLR sized tri-layer RGB Foveon sensor, with the x3 factor, 14 MP. Have you considered these?
The ~ $600 GR Digital II already has a following because of the pedigree of its quality fixed 28mm lens and the unique grain (some would call it "horrible", others "distinctive") of the B&W images it can produce. For sure, the camera reacts fast and is blessed with perhaps the best set of buttons for manual control of everything including "favorite settings".
For the well received Ricoh, it's the fast lens that is the selling point. "The key criteria for lens performance , sharpness and low distortion, have been pursued without compromise. The widely acclaimed F2.4/f:5.9mm lens (35mm equivalent: 28mm) features improvements to compensate for various types of aberrations and vignetting on the subject's periphery - areas that are particularly problematic - to provide outstanding sharpness and high contrast all the way to the corners of the image as the data in the lens' MTF curve demonstrates. This achieves high image quality particularly when taking pan-focus shots. Other refinements include reduction in mechanical noise from the AF drive during focusing. The GR Lens is the story of constant efforts at improvement. The more the user understands photography, the more he or she will want to put this lens to use.
The brightness of a F2.4 aperture and various aberration compensation. The superb optical performance of the GR Lens is achieved by a 5-group, 6 element lens that incorporates 3-groups with 2 aspherical elements and high-precision assembly techniques for sharper images in a more compact size. Use of high quality optical glass and special lens polishing and multi-coating technologies ensure natural colour renditions, overall sharpness and excellent contrast characteristics. The design of an original "retracting lens system" allows for the lens to draw level into a thin, 25mm camera body. In the course of the lens retracting a portion of the optical system withdraws from atop of the optical axis, thereby realizing extreme high-precision and control of the lens unit - a successful merger of exceptional optical performance within a slim body form you can carry with you anywhere." Source.
I am impressed how photographers have become religiously attached to the Ricoh, even embracing the noise as some character like we might remark on in swirling a taste of a great wine. There's lens adapters to provide focal lengths equivalent 40mm and 21mm. Fans even crave versions with these 40mm and 21mm focal lengths and it seems many would carry all three! Hello guys! What's the point of a compact if you are schlepping a whole compendium of lenses and or variants!
I however, look to the upcoming ~ $800 Sigma DP1, for far greater quality image implied. A more impressive picture is expected from the Foveon sensor, as found in in the flagship Sigma SD14 DSLR. After a puzzling delay which appears to have been a matter of getting the last software quirks solved, the 28mm fixed lens DP1 is due out in Europe and the USA in weeks. The Sigma company has put both it's flagship larger Foveon sensor and it's lens expertise into its compact DP1 offering. "Sigma DP1 compact digital camera featuring a 14 megapixel FOVEON X3 direct image sensor (2652 _ 1768 _ 3 layers) as used in the Sigma SD14 digital SLR."
"16.6mm F4 LENS DESIGNED EXCLUSIVELY FOR THE DP1
The DP1 is equipped with a 16.6mm F4 lens, equivalent to 28mm on a 35mm SLR camera, which has been designed exclusively for DP1. The large-diameter of aspherical glass provides low distortion and high contrast images. It also offers superior peripheral brightness. The super multi-layer coating reduces flare and ghosting. It allows photographers to take pictures in difficult light conditions. This lens and SLR-sized image sensor provides natural shallow depth-of-field." Source Sigma
Well, what about the Sigma not having the 40mm lens for portraits? Just take the image and crop! What about a 21mm attachment like the Ricoh? Turn the camera vertically and take adjacent overlapping pictures. That's what stitching is for. One camera for everything! However, I'd guess it will be best used at ISO settings at 400 and below given the performance of the same sensor in the Sigma DSLR. At the lower ISOs one should get really wonderful color.
Asher
Last edited: