HOME FORUMS NEWS FAQ SEARCH 

Imaging Technology: Theory, Alternatives, Practice and Advances. This is a brand independent discussion of theory, process or device. Ignore this forum unless this matters to you! 

Thread Tools  Display Modes 
#1




Defining more than routine 3axis "Color Space" from a camera imaging system..
Asher
__________________
Follow us on Twitter at @opfweb Our purpose is getting to an impressive photograph. So we encourage browsing and then feedback. Consider a link to your galleries annotated, C&C welcomed. Images posted within OPF are assumed to be for Comment & Critique, unless otherwise designated. 
#2




Hi, Asher,
Quote:
Bu that is not to say that other transforms (mathematicallyredundant) cannot help us to better grasp the significance of color, or the working of colorhandling chains. A parallel in another realm is this. If we have a vessel that is a closed cylindrical cylinder, we can completely describe it (physically) in terms of two parameters, perhaps length and diameter. But, in a catalog of cylindrical air tanks, it is certainly useful to state perhaps length, diameter, and volume (and in a setting where this would be of any consequence, perhaps surface area as well). In engineering, this is spoken of as "overspecifying" the vessel: we dare not, in specifying the construction of one, give length, diameter, and volume, not just because it is not needed, but because our values may conflict. But when our purpose is to describe, rather than specify, this can in fact be very useful. Another parallel is this. We can completely define the location of a point on the earth's surface in terms of its latitude and longitude. But it may be very useful, in describing the location of a radio tower, to not only describes its location in terms of latitude and longitude, but also in terms of coordinates in a mapping system, and also in terms of its location as a certain distance off the the side of the centerline of a particular highway at a certain milepost. Now, can we think of a sixdimensional space in which the axes are: • Latitude and longitude • Easting and Northing on a grid • Milepost and offset distance on some stated highway. Yes, we can. But not all points in such a space are valid  only those whose latitude and longitude coordinates are consistent with their Easting and Northing coordinates and with their milepost and offset coordinates. That's actually only a tiny fraction of all the points in the space. Since a sixdimensional space has no physical realization, I cannot describe this "sparse" space as comprising, for example, only a bunch of little threads. But it is conceptually much like that. To get back to something we can better visualize, let's return to our universe of air tanks, for which we can have a length, a diameter, and (not independently) a volume. If we imagine a three dimensional space on which we will plot all available (or even all possible) air tanks, we find that they all must lie on a surface  the surface the satisfies the mathematical relationship between diameter, length, and volume. So it is really only a "two dimensional plot on a nonflat surface". But it could still be very useful to the connoisseur of air tanks. Now as to what kind of "overspecified" color model might be valuable to us, we would first have to be able to articulate its objectives. In what way could we better visualize something about a color, and what, than in any threedimensional description? What is it that we need to improve our appreciation of? It is an interesting challenge. Best regards, Doug 
#3




Quote:
of an image of a giant standard perfect color wheel in lights of different spectral makeup. Asher
__________________
Follow us on Twitter at @opfweb Our purpose is getting to an impressive photograph. So we encourage browsing and then feedback. Consider a link to your galleries annotated, C&C welcomed. Images posted within OPF are assumed to be for Comment & Critique, unless otherwise designated. 
#4




Hi, Asher,
Quote:
Regarding a "color wheel" as the test target, note that no twodimensional target can represent all colors  even all colors within some restricted gamut. You can make a color wheel that exhibits, for example, all hues over some range of saturations (perhaps different by hue) at a uniform luminance, or some other twodimensional subset of the color space. Best regards, Doug 
#5




Quote:
Asher
__________________
Follow us on Twitter at @opfweb Our purpose is getting to an impressive photograph. So we encourage browsing and then feedback. Consider a link to your galleries annotated, C&C welcomed. Images posted within OPF are assumed to be for Comment & Critique, unless otherwise designated. 
#6




Hi Asher,
Re: Does the color map have to be in 3D space? If you have 3 primary colours thats it  3space. Any colour is a linear combination of the 3 primary colours. To produce a colour picture we have 3 planes each plane being an (n x m) matrix where n and m are the size of the image in pixels. The following are defined in the 3space. * accuracy * transitions between colors * uniformity * bias Eg. Transition between colours may be measured (in the physical space of the image) by considering the gradient vector but this is still in the 3D colour space. But does this have meaning? I really don't know  Iv'e not tested it!! To represent a point in 3space you need 3 numbers  we are use to x,y and z. OK? We may also say that this point is on the side of a cylinder  need 3 numbers in cylindrical coordinates !! Of course we can say that this point lies on the surface of a sphere need 3 numbers in spherical coordinates. The absolute position of the point has not changed we just find different ways of representing it. Regards, Jeremy, 
#7




Hi, Jeremy,
I'm delighted to hear of your interest in the philosophy and application of these concepts. It is an important field. Quote:
The realm of such a coordinate system containing all colors (often said "visible colors", but of course only visible radiation has the property of color) can be, by parallel to the notion of a number space, be called the color space of the coordinate system. But in modern times, the term color space has been hijacked to mean a fullydefined (and "recognized") threedimensional system of describing color, revolving around a certain color model (coordinate scheme) further particularized as to the scale and nature of its coordinates (including, perhaps, nonlinear scaling of an underlying parameter), in the case of a tristimulus color model by definition of the colors of its "primaries", and so forth. Some of these are based on a Cartesian coordinate model and some on a cylindrical coordinate model. I know of no recognized color space predicated on a spherical coordinate model. Perhaps you have already read my extensive article, "Color and Color Spaces", available here: http://dougkerr.net/Pumpkin#Color Best regards, Doug 
#8




Hi Doug,
WRT to colour in photography etc. I'm still on the learning curve  somewhere at the bottom 1/4 !!!. Re: Some of these are based on a Cartesian coordinate model and some on a cylindrical coordinate model. I'm sure there is a very good reason  but I don't know it. One could play games for example: If one converts from cartesian (x,y,z) to the spherical (rho, theta, phi) the same looking colour is there but if one were to change one of the angles (theta or phi) then convert back to f(x,y,z) the colours will change in an interesting fashion  each angle will change 2 dimensions. This could make "crazy" distortions in the colours in the original picture  better than LSD lol. Regards, Jeremy. 
#9




Hello gentlemen,
When posting about matters of color (rather than lightness or value) I prefer CIELAB a*b* or hue and saturation in HSV. I find that is about as much as most folks can take, especially those entrenched in the 3D world of RGB. best, Ted 
#10




Hi, Ted,
Quote:
HSV is a very problematical quantitative color coordinate system, but the qualitative concepts are easily understood by humans. You might find this article of interest: http://dougkerr.net/Pumpkin/index.htm#HSVHSLBest regards, Doug 
#11




Quote:
Quote:
best, Ted 
Bookmarks 
Thread Tools  
Display Modes  


Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
News: The Canon 7D is big news! Fast accurate focus and low light capability!  Asher Kelman  Breaking News  10  September 1st, 2009 09:09 AM 
News: Camera that auto stitches and auto builds from multiple shots!  Asher Kelman  Breaking News  1  March 3rd, 2009 06:30 AM 
Panoramic photography  choice of pivot axis  Doug Kerr  Panorama Photography: Vistas, Interiors & Objects  17  February 19th, 2009 03:01 PM 
new Mamiya DL28 Digital Camera System  leonardobarreto.com  Medium Format & Large Format Cameras  6  October 15th, 2008 10:32 PM 
New Sinar Hy665 Camera System and Hy6s65r (31 MPx) Announced  Thierry Hagenauer  Medium Format & Large Format Cameras  9  September 4th, 2008 06:41 PM 