Tom, I believe you have totally misjudged my POV… I had my Bronica ETRS system all the way from the 80's until I was forced to change for Contax 645 to be able to use a multishot back (otherwise I wouldn't change)…, and my MFDB, I have no thoughts of replacing it, although it is already 9 years old… neither I plan to change from Contax to another modern camera. My Sinar P2 and accessories, I replaced for S/H Fuji GX680 (much to my favour financially, I had a good amount of money left) because I needed a huge investment to make the Sinar fully compatible with my MFDB's multishot abilities and additionally because the image area of my MFDB is of much lesser size than what both Sinar or Fuji are capable of… My first DSLR was the Fuji S5 on 2007, strictly because I was still be using Nikon film until that time and I wanted to keep my lenses many of which have been bought (again) during the 80's… My film cameras up to 2007 where the Nikon F3s …again bought on the 80s! I never had an F4 or F5 or F6…
I don't like to change equipment… in fact I hate it when I have to do so… So we are in agreement here! But, with digital being new and hence tech developments advancing at faster rhythm, we all have to admit that "sharpening the pencils" as far as sensors are concerned, is like using 20's film if compared to 90's film… I believe (judging from D4's sensor and D800e's one which are the DSLRs I now use, that next generation improvement will slow down a lot to a degree where replacement may seem pointless… So… I don't have on my mind wether to replace my D4's sensor or the (much different) D800's one, but I can tell you, D4's sensor is so much better than D700's, to a degree that one can be certain that his photography will be improved…
Can you remember me being enthusiastic on the possible release of a camera with interchangeable sensor? …it's because I don't like changing stuff Tom… we are much in agreement here… but film… that is really like "sharpening one's pencils"...
You don't have to try and convince me, Theo. we are heading in different directions for different reasons. For me, all this technical stuff goes over my head most of the time. My mental space doesn't have room for it. It's like telling a fish it could just as well get its oxygen easier and faster if it came out of water. Or more emphatically, tell a long distance runner he is better off catching a train.
You and I don't do what we do for the same reasons. Nor do we apply the same processes, equipment, strategies or even logic. We might both be photographers in our own way but to the large part, that's where it stops. Unlike you, my chosen career has been in the field of teaching. A critical aspect of teaching is to recognize there are many ways to eat an apple and just as many people to choose their own way. Personally, I like mine cored, sliced into segments and chilled. That may seem a bit anal to some but so, for me, does your approach to photography.
But, you know, it's OK. You get what you want, I get what I want.
What I do notice, though, is that many students don't know this **** when they start off. In fact, some long time amateurs still hang onto it. One size fits all philosophy is alive and well and lives on the internet, in the stores, on the designers table and the sales persons shop. "The better the camera the better the photograph" hasn't died yet. Sure, we all shudder when we hear it, but we do chase it to the ground and embrace it from time to time.
I guess what I am trying to do here, in my own sarcastic and biting way, is to provide a bit of balance to the discussion. I don't know what your intentions are in photography. I'm not that interested. But I am interested in the decisions people make when considering improving their craft. Of course you are partially correct in what you say. I'm suggesting another option.
We all seem to be in a hurry. You think it's worth waiting for a couple of years for the next but one new model to come forward, hoping it will make a marginal difference and I'm heading back to my 7 year old digital model and browsing through eBay for a Rollieflex hoping it will make a marginal difference to my photography. That's because we are from different places, Theo.
we will never agree but we can encompass each other's thoughts without fear of favour.